Better with Humans Podcast

AI Coaching Limits: What AI Misses

Watch the Better with Humans Podcast on YouTube
Watch and listen to the Better with Humans Podcast on Spotify
Watch and listen to the Better with Humans Podcast on Apple Podcasts
Listen to the Better with Humans Podcast on Amazon Music

 

I have a shelf of books I've never read. I call it the shelf of shame, and it is the perfect illustration of where the AI coaching limits really start to show. The information is right there. Good information, useful information, the kind that would genuinely move me forward. I just haven't picked it up. Dr Keith Webb joined me to talk about why that gap exists, and why no amount of better information is going to close it.

Coaching draws out, it doesn't put in

Keith makes a clean distinction. Teaching, advising and mentoring are all about putting in. Giving people frameworks, grids, techniques. Coaching sits at the other end of that scale. It draws out. It helps someone reflect on what is going on inside them, around them, and in the wider system they sit in, so they can get clearer about what they actually want and then go and do something about it. That difference matters more than it sounds, because most of us are not short on input.

Why the AI coaching limits show up so quickly

Ask a chatbot how to cut sugar out of your diet and you will get a beautiful plan. You still won't do it. Keith pointed to studies where people are told by medical professionals that they will die within months unless they change, and the vast majority still don't. That is not an information problem. That is an implementation problem. And implementation problems live under the surface, in conflicting values and deeply worn habits. I want to be fit. I also want the cake. No plan solves that.

The agreeable machine

Keith's biggest concern is how agreeable these tools are by default. You can tell them to challenge you. Most people never do. So you get warm validation for thinking that deserved a harder look. A good coach notices the pause, the word choice, the resistance in the voice, and pulls on a thread you didn't offer. New coaches miss that too, which tells you something. It is a skill, not a feature.

Beauty in imperfection

We landed somewhere I didn't expect. Vulnerability only works both ways. People share freely with a machine because there is no cost to it, but nothing comes back. No frailty, no worry, no admission of a mistake. Keith reached for wabi-sabi, the Japanese idea of beauty in imperfection, the cracked bowl repaired with gold and made more precious for it. That is what two humans in a room actually bring each other.

So here is what I'm sitting with. The question isn't whether a machine can generate a good question. It's whether I'd bother being honest with it. Keith's work is at creativeresultsmanagement.com, and his writing is at keithwebb.com. Go and have a look.

Connect with Keith Webb:

LinkedIn
Website
X
Keith's book, The COACH Model for Christian Leaders
Keith Webb’s Blog

More conversations like this

  • Finding the Right Mentor FastFinding the Right Mentor Fast. Peter Lynagh picks up the human side from another angle, on admitting you need help, testing chemistry with a mentor, and using AI to grow people rather than cut them.
  • Redemptive Leadership That HealsRedemptive Leadership That Heals. Brian Schroller talks about being seen and heard, and why the pain you have lived through is what qualifies you to sit with someone else in theirs.
  • Online Course Student Results That Actually StickOnline Course Student Results That Actually Stick. Nathalie Doremieux builds AI tools at the points where people get stuck, helping them implement rather than writing the thing for them.

This was made with humans.

Your host - Shaun Phillips

Editor: Glen Boswell
astralforgefilm.com
Instagram

Original music composed and produced by Brokli

Original logo illustration and in video podcast graphics by Jesse Rist

Follow us for episode clips on Instagram

Follow us on TikTok

Want to watch episodes instead? Subscribe on YouTube

Connect with Shaun on LinkedIn

Introduction

0:04 I have a shelf of books I've not read. I call it the shelf of shame. If there's good stuff in there, things that would generally help me, I've just not picked them up. My guest today would say that shelf is the whole problem in miniature. We assume we are stuck because we are missing information. Usually we're not. We know exactly what to do. We're just not doing it. My guest today is Dr. Keith Webb. I first met Keith in April 2025 when I took his Coaching Mastery Foundations course.

0:32 Keith is the founder and president of Creative Results Management, a leader development organisation focused on equipping and coaching skills. He's the author of the best-selling book, The Coach Model for Christian Leaders. He lived in Asia for 20 years and now lives near Seattle. So welcome, Keith. It's great to have you on this show. Yeah, thanks for having me on, Shaun. Well, I wanted to have you on because just coaching is just one of those things that we are seeing impacted by AI.

1:00 It's one of those areas. It's one of those areas where people are saying, well, why can't I just get AI to coach me? And I know we'll talk a little bit around that as we go through this episode.

What coaching actually is

1:11 But first of all, I think it would be great to just have a definition on coaching just so we can ground people where we are. Well, coaching for me is in contrast to a lot of teaching, a lot of advising, a lot of mentoring, which is putting in. Where we're giving people information, input. Our grids, our frameworks, and so on. The other end of the scale from putting in is drawing out.

1:39 It's drawing out from people. Coaching is helping people to reflect on what's going on inside of them, around them, in their larger system. Helping them to reflect on that and to get clearer about what's happening and what they want and then do something about it. And so I don't know if that's actually a definition there. But functionally, that's how it's quite different.

2:05 Well, that's actually really interesting you put it that way. Because I think in terms of technology, I've seen this myself doing the same thing. One of the challenges that I see is what you spoke about is you're having this conversation and things are coming out. So the client, the person being coached is discovering things, uncovering things within themselves that comes out. Now, what I've seen in terms of when people are using.

2:32 Apps or technology or whatever to be coached is you're kind of presenting what you want the app to see. Now, you can do some of that within coaching. But obviously, as coaches, we are looking at what else is going on. We're trying to sort of help them navigate that side of things.

Why change is so hard

2:52 So in terms of change, we're talking about coaching people being able to change. I was seeing AI coming along and being like, OK, we're having. To change because of AI. But in terms of. Coaching being about change and about how we people navigate that want to change or not to change, what are some of the challenges you find people have in terms of changing?

3:17 Now, the challenges are almost always internal, so we tend to think that our challenge for why we're not changing or why we can't achieve something we want to achieve, or there's a habit I'm trying to shift and I can't. Shift that habit, why can't and it's like I need it. I need something out there. I need more know how I need some new information or some technique and maybe Shaun knows it or maybe Keith knows or maybe somebody else knows it right or or maybe I knows it and we try and get we try and get that information.

3:51 But what I find is, is that is usually not the problem. I mean, think about fitness, fitness and and so on. We all know what to do. We know what. Healthy eating looks like. We know what healthy movement and exercise looks like. It's not a knowledge issue. It's something else.

Conflicting values and habits

4:12 And those it's actually more than one something. It's probably a series of something else's and it's often internal and it's things like conflicting values. So I want to be fit, but I want to eat that cake. I want to be fit, but I also want to be comfortable. And I don't want. To go out and exercise in the rain or I don't want to get up first thing in the morning and do core crunches or something like that.

4:42 So it's a conflicting it's conflicting internal values and conflicting habits that we have. So this are we have habits which are deeply ingrained in us and it takes a lot to change those habits. So change is not easy. Change is not a matter of giving them. New information. And that's what most people think. They the most people think why they're not changing is they don't have the right information, the right technique.

5:12 So therefore, if I get it from you or a teacher or somewhere else or the Internet or AI that I will change, but they don't change.

Why information alone changes nothing

5:23 And there's famous studies of medical professionals where they diagnose someone with a certain disease. Or certain diseases and they say, unless you change your lifestyle in these ways, you will die six months from now to nine months from now, if you change your lifestyle, you could live another three or four years and the vast majority of people do not change.

5:51 And that is not an information problem. That's an implementation problem. And that's where coaching particular teaching and advising and all that. That's if that solves information problems, but implementation problems is often is usually internal to the person and that's a different those are different processes entirely. Absolutely it makes it reminds me of my books over here.

6:17 I call it the shelf of shame, you know, and these are these books that I still have to read. I still need to read and it reminds me back to the exact thing, isn't it? Of well, actually, I've got these books. I had some brilliant stuff in there. I'm bound to get some good nuggets from there. They're going to help me develop. Going to help me grow. But until I pick them up and actually read the books, and even as you're saying, that's only part of the process, isn't it? Part of the process is I can read those things and then maybe I'll pick something out of it.

6:43 But then there's another choice to be made. Do I actually implement that? Actually, when you go through coaching, you have the opportunity for somebody to support you in that and help you to understand what is holding you back. You were saying, what are some of the conflicting values? Well, okay. Yeah. Well, I liked it. I hear it the same as well. When I'm coaching people, I hear the same thing of, well, yeah, I know I should do this. I know I should do that. And I know these things are good for me, but I don't.

Giving accountability back to the client

7:12 One of the things that actually I really found useful in terms of the coach model, the way that you train the coaching was on the accountability thing, which is a little bit when I've talked about people, it's like a bit counterintuitive because their idea is that, okay, well, normally, I mean, if I'm coaching somebody, they want me to be the one that's holding them accountable. Okay, right.

7:39 Well, I'm going to, what are your action steps? Well, they're these things. And they want me to be the one to say, and that's a traditional way of doing it. I've seen a lot of cases where the next time you go, right, how did you get on with X, Y, and Z? I mean, yeah, the way that you've taught us is actually leave it to them, leave it to them to be, you know, they're sharing it with you. So they know you've made a note, but just going, how's that?

8:05 I speak on it every time people come back and they'll say, oh, well, I did this and this. Oh, I didn't do that. And you didn't even prompt them to do that. But I have seen better results definitely from almost giving the accountability back to the person to say, well, it's up to you to make a note of that. It's up to you to be the one to follow through with that. It's not up to me to be the one that is going to chase you down on those. It's, it's,

8:30 it's this draw out function, right? So in school, we're often given an external in. So we're taught and then we're held accountable for what we're taught. So we, so someone's, you know, my mother, my teacher telling me that I need to have studied that, right? Whereas in coaching, we're going after the internal, internal desires, internal accountabilities. So I do ask people,

9:00 what progress have you made on your action steps? But I'm not doing it as this external accountability, you know, playing the heavy person of you're going to be penalised, but it's more of you said you wanted to do this. You made a plan regarding it. What and I'm curious about what you did on that and how you evaluate that. So it's all about what what they're after.

9:28 So it's what they want. It's what they planned for. It's what they did for their own reasons. And I keep drawing back to that because it's easy for people to say, well, I don't have to make you happy Keith or I'm not you Keith. So I don't need to live up to your standard. It's like exactly hundred percent. You do not but you have a standard and you have a desire and you had goals. How are you living up to those?

9:54 And that is way more powerful. I think in bringing change to people. It does help to have somebody outside of themselves asking it, you know, there is still a little bit of external when I when we have a conversation with someone and draw out that stuff, but it's a matter of getting people to tap into their own motivations and their own values when someone says, yeah, I already know what to do,

10:21 but I don't push in anything on why they should do it anymore. Now, I want to ask about what's the, but what's in the way, what's the conflicting thing? That's that's keeping you from doing what you say you want to do. That's that's where the leverage is for change. I believe. Yeah, absolutely. It says say I've got something on my board over here. So getting from some being caught being coached and one of the things challenges was motivation.

10:52 So why am I not getting these things done? What we can't got down to was all this a problem with the motivation. So then we did that. Dug into what motivates me. So I've got four things that I know these four things and motivate me. So now if I'm having a troubling motivation, I go, okay, which which is missing, which is missing it. Is there a external deadline? Is there is there actually some something fun in doing this? What the other things? Am I moving towards something and improvement aspects to it?

11:19 Is there a problem to solve? So there's things that now I can recognise, but I still need to go back and look at, you know, I just just did remind myself. Okay, what other? What is missing in that? And this is anything, isn't it? This idea that. We may not consciously understand everything about how our minds work, but actually it's in there somewhere. And if we can, if we can draw that out and understand, we only we know that and I think that is one of the challenges.

11:47 And when we talk about and we hear about people using AI for coaching as mentioned earlier, this that we are we are putting on how do we expect AI? To dig in? When you dig in and yeah, how do you see that?

Human coaching versus AI coaching

12:02 How do you see the sort of differences between a human human coaching and an AI coaching? But what there's lots of levels to that answer. So if if the coaching issue is simply a problem-solving type thing, then perhaps a I can do fine by, you know, you ask your question.

12:28 I'm having trouble getting this done. What are some approaches I could take to it? And then you get four approaches to it. Oh, I'm going to do that one, right? But that's very that's very simple low-level and that is that could be coached. It could be but it's very low-level. It's not what people are paying a coach bigger money for you're not going to go to a coach for that. You're going to go to a friend or you're going to look it up on the internet or whatever.

12:57 And so I can do that. Fine. They can give you that ideas. But when it comes to when it comes to for example, the medical situation where someone has a certain disease and they they need to cut out for example, all sugar out of their diet, just for example, they have to cut out all sugar out of their diet, but they have trouble doing that.

13:24 That's where you're going to have where I see. The way at least the way people most people use AI is they would say how can I do this? And it AI will give you a beautiful plan for cutting sugar out of your diet and replacing it with other things and so on and so on, but they won't do it. And the not doing it is the gap there. And and so they're looking for they're using AI as a set of they're looking at they're using AI for information. And that's,

13:58 that isn't the problem. Information is not the options are not the problem. People already have usually have at least one good option. They could try out and then that gets them moving and then they find out and discover things along the way. So we have that stuff. So I see people are using AI for information. I think that's a big problem. The another big problem is most people's AI is set up to agree with them.

14:25 So if you if you say, I'm having I'm struggling getting sugar out of my diet. Well, that's so understandable. I can understand that sugar tastes so good and who wouldn't want to not have cake and ice cream, you know this this it's not quite that agreeable, but it is quite agreeable and and most people don't go into a chat with an AI and say be disagreeable with me,

14:50 which is it can do and would be help more helpful probably in that. But I think there's also, a deeper level that I think currently anyway, AI is unable to do to pick up on some of the nuance or the slight pauses in people's tone or the word they chose or the word choice and we just innately as humans.

15:20 If you once you get tuned into listening to people and hearing them, we pick up on these little tiny things. Differently, so it's not you do you wouldn't see it in a transcript. So if AI is functionally just, you know, if we're typing, it's just a transcript, right? You don't catch the emotion, the tone, the pacing, the nuance like that,

15:45 like the conversation we're having now that could change, but at least currently that's not what's going to happen. And I think that so I think AI is great for small love or, uh, you know, small level problem solving things like I need some options, which options or I'm having trouble with this, what, you know, just kind of tasky things. But when it gets into really internal like change my leadership communication,

16:12 it's not a the leadership communication. That's a common one. For example, how I communicate as a leader, right? You can get they'll tell you all be nicer, you know, share the store share stories. They'll tell you all the technique. The problem is, is usually some other thing inside of you that says I need to be this way if I'm going to be like this and I want to be like that.

16:37 So I act that way and so these things are the things that need to be explored. So it's almost like change doesn't happen straight on all the time. If it's a low-level problem, you can just change straight on but but deeper level change needs to come round about it and I'm from under the surface. Usually. Yeah, and I can see that and it's also as you were talking to me.

17:03 Think about how we talked about this before. We start the podcast was actually a I built up a memory. Of course, it builds that up of the things that we information that we give it. So it's as you said, his responses are going to be biased or they're going to be using that information. It's it's got whereas when you come to a coach for the first time knows nothing about you, then they're going to be wanting to understand them in a big deeper in some respects.

17:32 And so the thing you want to you want to work through but also something else that I've noticed is

Knowing when to pull a different thread

17:37 and I think this again, I think I would struggle with is when actually you recognise as a coach that maybe this isn't the thing they really want to deal with and maybe yeah, there's another threads to pull you go. Okay, you mentioned this maybe we want to pull that thread and that doesn't seem to me like that. Something at the moment that I would necessarily think to do because you've given it a task help me solve this problem.

18:05 And maybe it won't pull on the other thread. Yes. Yeah, I think currently it won't I think it could start to do that or it could be trained to do that. But the but it know it currently doesn't and in fact, so the way I see it, so I train coaches. This is what I do is train coaches. And when I see new coaches come in, I see them acting like the AI is like well, you said you wanted to work on this. So we just keep working on it. Even though when I listen to the conversation of them coaching together,

18:33 I can see this the coaching client doesn't or isn't acting like they actually want it. There's some resistance there. And so it's like we're not on the we might be on the right bigger topic, but we're not on the right subtopic of it because there's resistance there, right? And so I pick that up but my but new coaches don't pick that up. And I think similarly AI doesn't necessarily pick that up

19:01 or it hasn't been trained to pick it up. But it does as you say Shaun it it does require going back and and revisiting this a I find it, you know saying I find it curious as we've every look as we looked at it this way and this way and this way. I'm curious about what you're seeing in this. I'm curious about where your motivation is is at with all of this where you're going.

19:26 And so it's it's almost like a push back. And that's that's my big thing with AI right now is is AI is just too agreeable right now. It's just too agreeable. It's too nice and agrees with us. And again, we can you can tell it to don't be nice and don't be agreeable and give me, you know, play devil's advocate with me and do that. But most people don't and so they just go along and and AI tells them that all of their thoughts and ideas are bad.

19:56 Those are brilliant when they're not because we're not asking it the right things. And that's the thing is when your coach when you're coaching client, you're not asking you're usually sharing you got somebody else asking and that's what a good coach does a good coach asks the questions. That's going to cause you to think differently or think in new ways, right not not forcing them towards a solution,

20:22 but just getting them to reflect differently than they are reflecting now. And then they can compare that to how they've been thinking about it with the way they're reflecting now and see what they see. That's what we're trying to get it to do. That's what we're trying to get to happen in coaching. That's good coaching. Yeah, I can and I can see that and it just is it's so interesting as well. I think in terms of I just thought I lost my train of thought.

20:49 I was just thinking about what you were saying about what I can and can't do. I just thinking think I have motivation. So actually a motivation. What is a as motivation, you know, it's it's not naturally curious. So in terms of so unless you say unless we're telling it, you know, you'd be tenaciously curious and continue to do that. Well, it's not it's not going to do that. But also what is motivation because as coaches we go into a space with a client and our motivation is is is might differ.

21:19 But often the motivations can be we want to help them. Achieve the goals achieve the goals that they've come in with and they spoken about it's okay. We're going to work together. And as we go through you might deviate on some what we can do in a particular session, but we're helping you each session to do what they need to do to progress to the next stage. They want to get to and I think and I start thinking about it and think well, I can't see how you know,

21:44 the only motivation that comes my eye is you as you as the client going to AI and saying you are motivated to help me solve the problem, which I don't think I can't really see how that's ever really going to be. The same as even when we talk about AI being even more sophisticated. It might be able to simulate that but whether I don't see it ever becoming something that says I'm going to have a natural human curiosity and the motivation to help.

Every coach brings a different lens

22:11 Well, and even there is the it's natural human or let's say curiosity and motivation to help through what through what lenses. So Shaun your personality my personality were different. We have different experiences. We have different backgrounds. We have different motivations in even when we meet with people and coach and so I coach people differently. I work with Rachel for example,

22:38 and Rachel and I often lead training demonstrations. And when we're done we often say one to the other both of us are instructors. Both of us are certified coaches and we'll say one to the other. That was amazing. I would have never asked that or I would have never gone down. That's read with that person and yet we would have had a great conversation with that person, but the conversations ended up looking quite differently because we're different people

23:08 and that I think is the that that's the humaneness. So curiosity. I mean you can have a form of curiosity, but my curiosity is going to come out of my filter and my background and my experience. Of life and how I see things but a different coaches curiosity is going to come out of her background and life place and season in life and age and experience

23:37 and personality and it's going to be a different experience. And so I think there's a lot of that that humaneness. Oh, then there's the frailties. So we try as coaches we try and get rid of our our biases and our judgements and you know, the kind of the negative things, which basically your experience and your personality and all that is a bias and a judgement, you know, because you think it's a good question.

24:03 So you ask it right? Well, why do you think that? Well, you think that because of of who you are, right? So but we but in terms of negative biases or judgements and so on we try and weed those things out. But yet we don't want to weed out everything is human. We don't want to we don't want to do that. And sometimes the fact so I'm a super results, oriented person. We don't get to go certainly not multiple coaching sessions

24:31 without going after something. I mean trying to go for something that's my personality. And so maybe it's a flaw that I'm to results focused but it turns into the humaneness of the interaction of I push an idea focused person who just wants to stay up with ideas. I push them to action just even without even trying.

24:56 I just do it in my in my the way I work with someone and so it's going to be different for every every human coach. We'll have a different you come you ask from different grids. You process the conversation from your own background and personality and who you are. And I think that's an asset. I think that's actually a beautiful picture because we're you know, where it means every experience you go into.

25:23 And you work with someone it means you're going to get different things out of it. You know that it's not just that it's not a cookie cutter thing that says well, okay, this person is going to be out there, you know, maybe somebody's very empathic. So if there's somebody that really isn't really giving away a lot in terms of what they're in in terms of their words, but they're giving a lot of away in their facial expressions or their breathing or their sighing then that coach is going to be much more able to draw those things out

25:52 and go what's going on there. I just you know, it's a big sigh what was happening there and be able to pull out on those things. Whereas somebody else might be much better at actually weeding and in navigating in between the actual things that are going on and your chest reminded me of a story for quite a long time ago. Actually now is back when I I first started I did some NLP training and had somebody call me up and they're like, oh yeah, I want to I want to you know,

26:19 resolve some problems and and they told me that they tried everything. I've enlisted all these things they tried and and I had been warned by my coach by my instructor to basically be careful. Sometimes people just want to give stuff a go, you know, they want to try things out. And in the end I realised this and she said I would this I think it was called EFT tapping. But there was a technique because I think it's a work for me and I said,

26:44 well, I think what if you decide something's going to work for you, you got a good chance is going to it's going to work for you, right? Because they're I mean, I didn't work for that. Person because I realised that it sounded like they just wanted to go through the process rather than rather than change now.

Wanting to change but not changing

27:01 That's so far the things we've talked about have been around people. Wanting to change but actually what happens in the scenarios you seen where actually people don't necessarily they want to change but they but they don't. Well, I mean that's that's everybody coming to me for coaching wants to change, but they don't that's why they come so they're having trouble.

27:26 They're stuck. That's why they need the they've already used the resources around them to get tips and hints and helps and accountabilities and all this but it's not happening. So yeah, so what what what what specifically were you thinking of? Well, I think it just in terms of somebody's so there's a there's a there's a willingness to change, but they're having difficulty in doing.

27:52 That might be that's a better way of putting it. Yeah. Yeah. Well, that's yes. So that's that's what I think that's what I feel like most of my clients are there. They are will they say they're willing to change but they're well, so they are willing to change at one level and then they don't know why they're not changing, which which I'm saying is they're actually unwilling to change,

28:18 but they don't know why and so they don't see that this is under the surface. Here they have for example conflicting values or conflicting desires. So I want to be comfortable. So I won't do things that are uncomfortable, but I need to change my health habits or you know, or else and so that that's the that tension is what brings that tension.

28:44 I think is actually the human experience. We all want to be different than we are and we all make. Some we make some efforts to that and then we can't or you know, we can't make that progress or don't make that progress. So then what that's what you know, that that's what everybody's looking for. How do I what do I do about that?

29:10 Yeah, I think that and that is another great example of the human element in coaching of actually if I'm going to use AI. Then it's saying it's going to be what I. Decide I want to do and I might say I want to do something, but like you said at the start, maybe I don't follow it through. But when you're working with a coach over a series, we said, okay, we're going to work together for say 10 sessions and we've got an overall goal.

29:35 We want to achieve then you've got someone that is actually working with with you as you go like focus and helping when you do go. You know, I just I you know, I didn't really get anything done. I'm actually step starts week. Okay. Well what what could what could you have done differently? What what prevented you from doing that? What could you what would what would help you in achieving them in the next week? All these things that actually that as you say would more likely to get advice from AI,

30:01 but it's not necessarily going to be going to be proactive in that now.

What faith adds to coaching

30:06 One thing I think it would be interesting to talk about because one of the things so we mentioned that you you're for Christian. This is for your coaching Christian coaches. And so we talked about all of the human versus AI elements. But then what would you say? The difference is when we tend to when we say okay as Christians, we're going to coach. What do we what do we what else do we bring into that into that situation?

30:32 Well as a Christian, I believe that the Holy Spirit is working everywhere and with everyone and hold and God does provide some some sorts of guidance or promptings whether that's conscience. Or you know intuition or something which of course there's lots of intuition that is not God guided but so I see that happening.

31:02 And so my basic stance is that God does have desires for us and and is willing to empower us to do that. And we need to figure that we need to figure that out or get on his. His track with that and so for me when where that comes in for me Shaun is I don't look at my coaching client just as my coaching client and in my old days.

31:35 I would look at my coaching client and I would say, oh, I think they need to be like this and that would be my old days, right? And I would want to change them to how I thought they should be now as a coach and what the coaching industry would say is. We, we don't say that about what I want them to be. Now we say, what do you want to be? And I think that's good, but I think there's one more level and that is what does God want them to be?

32:04 What is God calling them to become and to do in the world their contribution in the world? And what is that? And so I don't know what that is. I'm assuming my client doesn't know what that is. But together we can begin to think through it and sort through it and get some discernment. But I do that through the filter of the client and the clients belief system in there. And so so for me, I'm in one sense.

32:41 I'm trying to help people live out what God's called them to become as a person and to do in the world how they how God's called them. To be in character and be in the in their actions, not how I think they should be, but what he thinks they should be. And it's a discernment process to figure out what that is. It reminds me in some sense is a big mystery and a big challenge, but you know,

33:10 I just roll with it and just go with it and and we've seen all kinds of amazing things happen. Well, I love how you put that intuition because I think there may be people watching. And they hear us talk about, you know, talk about Holy Spirit and they go, what is that? And really often we find that manifest ourselves in just it could be a thought. It could be a word in the head could be a picture that we see some sort of vision of something that we then might share with the client.

33:36 Because I just thought this may or may not, you know, with open hands, it may or may not relate to you. You may just be like, no, I don't even know what that's about. Or it might be something that they go. Oh, I remember once saying to somebody, I was talking to Sherry and they said, oh, and there was that. Rucksack with rocks in it. I said, oh, so, you know, and then and then there was something they did. They done as a teenager. So there was something that happened to the teenager where they were, where they were wearing rucksack and I'd have no way.

34:02 How could I possibly have known that wasn't something I could I could have known about. And I think the other thing, this is nice. It brings us back almost full circle. So we talked about the start with values and these conflicting values. And this thing about when we understand our purpose, like, what are we, what are we here for? When we understand, our identity. So like, as you say, who we are, you know, in, in the image of God and then who and then our values are clear. What are,

34:28 what are the things that we, we stand for? What are the things that we, you know, we'll, we will fight for. Then those are the things, how we make decisions. And I think when it comes to any use of AI, whether it's small or big, we have to come with that intentionality of saying, what is the purpose of the thing that we're doing? Why are we doing it? Does it actually align with, with my values? Is my use of what I'm the, whatever technology or tool or thing that I'm doing?

34:55 Does it align with that? If it doesn't align with that, why would you do it? And I see that with organisations as well. I don't, I see many organisations don't have those fundamental things of purpose, density and values. So then how can you make any change in the organisation expect to be follow on with you? They're like, why would I do that? Because I don't know the values, right? I, I come to, to do coaching with, to learn about coaching through creative results management. And I, it's clear to me are clear to me. I can see that.

35:23 And not only do I see the purpose density and the values in the organisation, I see it lived out through yourself and Rachel and others in, in how I'm interacted with in how I'm instructed, et cetera. And so there's a congruency. So I know what I'm going to get. And I think that's, that's so much of what we want to be, not just in businesses, but humans is people should really experience us as the, the same.

35:51 And wherever we are, wherever we are. Hmm. Yeah,

Espoused values versus real values

35:55 I agree what you're mentioning companies and values. I think one of the, the, one of the biggest issues and it's, this is a very human thing and it works out organizationally and companies is we have espoused values. So we say we believe in team and, you know, kindness and hard work and blah, blah, blah. But actually what the main value is, uh, get ahead, profit, you know, the certain things, right? So we,

36:27 we talk these up big, but what we really are after is, is this or these three over here. And so we, and there's a disjointedness between those two because we can, we can keep spouting all of our ideals over here, but then we continue to do the behaviours that achieve these things. Over here. And that is,

36:52 that's that kind of conflict. That's exactly what keeps us. That's what, that's why we say, I want to eat healthy and, and exercise and so on and so on. But we continue to do what we do over here and, and how they're, they're different. What a good coach will do is to shine a light on that, that, that those two things together.

37:19 And then ask the client to reflect on. So what's happening here. You say you're looking for all these things, but yet you continue to do these. What do you, what do you see there? How do you reconcile these things or what what's your, or is the, is it even disjointed, right? It's that's what it is. I think in companies, that's the big, that's the big issue. I think companies have a very clear practical values that they,

37:48 that everybody knows, but they're probably not the written values on the sign on the wall. And it's, it's good. It's sorting out the difference between these two things and what we're going to do about them. That makes that, that helps us to actually improve and grow. Yeah. I think also feeds back into what we spoke about earlier around how we use AI and instruct AI in the way to get us to result, right? If we, you know,

38:13 whether it needs to be more critical or challenge us, because there's a prime example. If I go in and say, yeah, and I've done these are my values. Okay. Those are your values. Great. Okay. I then do something filling questions means as all, but you know, you said these are your values, but you're actually doing this. Oh yeah. Yeah. But then now those are still my values, but you know, but I don't want to do this thing here, but, but actually I'm recording, you know, keeping your memory. Those are my,

38:39 those are my values. And so I'm not actually recognising that in that space, maybe there's something that I am doing that is, that is against my values. I'm not really getting necessarily that, that prompt in doing it. So, and we've talked about, I mean, we know the, the challenges of using AI and we know it's kind of, it's something that is here. It's available to us. What do you think of some of the, the positive,

Where AI genuinely helps

39:03 some of the elements that we can, and we talked about how some, we talked about how we can use it positively, but what are some of the other things that we think could be done in terms of coaching? Well, it, well, in terms of coaching, I mean, you, you can train AI to do a lot of things. So you could train AI to, for example, compare the coaching industry's standards behaviors.

39:29 You could train it to listen to a record or read a transcript and then tell me how I did as a coach. You could train it to do that somewhat, and it could give you a clue on that. Where, where I find AI is helpful, and I don't think this is limited to coaching, but where I find, AI helpful is let's say in the thinking and in the change bit, right? I'm not talking about doing admin. I use,

39:56 I use Claude to do admin tasks for me. So I'm not talking about that, but in the change function, for example, you know, you can ask Claude to be a thinking partner with you. Don't, you can tell it don't be agreeable with me. I want you to check my thinking and give me some questions to reflect on. And then when I reflect on it, don't be agreeable.

40:22 Ask me another question to probe deeper and, and you can maybe get Claude to do that for you a little or will do that. But see, it still depends on you as a person. And I think there's a different level of tenaciousness, maybe that or human encounter because at the same time we, we fully recognise AI is just a machine. It's just a, it's not, it's not a thing. It's not a person.

40:51 And there's some social contract, Shaun, that we've got when we have a conversation with another human being, even someone who's not an authority or a boss that we want to, I don't know. We, most people that we have a different, it's a different encounter than if when we encounter through a machine, I think that's why you've got so much craziness out there in the social media. And people say so many outrageous things. They have no,

41:16 no filter because it's not seen as a person. Social media is not, it's not seen. It's just seen as a thing out there. So they say all these wild hurtful things that they, that they maybe never would say to someone's face. And that, that difference, I think is a, I think that's a big difference in how we treat and process with an AI tool. Yeah, I agree.

41:45 And it actually makes me think as well is, I mean, I think we can turn it off. So there's the, you might, you might kind of like ghost your coach, whatever. And you might have somebody, I mean, I had somebody that I did, but that was just, I went quiet and eventually go back to me. Oh yeah. I just not really feel like I'm in the, I've got the time or whatever to do it. But, but I was eventually the had to have the conversation. Or even if you don't, there might be, so you might bump into them in the street.

42:11 There's always going to be a lingering thing, isn't there? Whereas with AI, if you like, you know what, I can just, I can just log out of chat GPT and I'll start fresh with Claude or whatever it is. So that, so I think there's a, as you say, there's psychologically when we have, we've seen this in accountability terms, when we hold ourselves accountable to other people, then that is so much stronger. And particularly if those people are willing to,

42:36 are invested in us and are willing to say, Hey, look, how are you getting on with this? Where'd you go with that? I've got one of my friends. He's brilliant at it. I'm going to have an official, your thing about accountability by 10. I'm going to do something. I'm pretty guaranteed. At some point, he will ask me, how would, how did you get on with that particular thing? Because that's just a natural, something that comes perfectly natural to him. And, and we're thankful and we're respectful of the person. We, we appreciate,

43:04 we see the talent and the busyness of the other person. And the fact that they'll even meet with us makes me want to level up. I want to, I want to level up my thinking. I want to level up my actions because you're willing to meet with me and the, and I respect you. And so we, whereas I don't think people give the same and always on AI, you don't have that same kind of respect or, you know,

43:32 that kind of relational dimension accountability, but which I think naturally comes through in a human relationship. Yeah.

Vulnerability goes both ways

43:41 And actually makes me think about, I'm just, just, I just occurred to me, but I'm not really sure. You could be vulnerable as in eyes. I mean, you might be sharing stuff with AI, but, but in terms of, I mean, there's some issues around that in itself, in terms of what's getting trained, what potentially could be used for training data on that. There's that aspect of it. So maybe you wouldn't want to be vulnerable, but also I just think in terms of,

44:06 as I think about person and thinking, well, why is it vulnerable sharing? You know, if you just, you're sharing to a machine, I think, I think that takes, maybe takes away the senses as a human to a human being vulnerable to somebody else is one. As you say, it means the person you've been vulnerable to is like, oh, wow, this, this person is, you know, this is costing them something. So therefore I need to be attentive.

44:31 I need to do what I can to support them because that's costing them something to be that vulnerable. Yeah. Well, yeah, it can, it invulnerable goes both ways, right? So for example, I think a lot of people are super, vulnerable to an AI tool because there's no accountability. There is no human dimension there and they think it's anonymous. It's like writing in a diary back in the day. But one of the things that I don't see is there's no vulnerability coming back.

45:00 Now coaches don't tell, I don't tell my stories. I don't tell all my stuff to my clients, but they feel my vulnerability even as I'm talking with them because I'm not like a machine talking with people. They feel my selection of words or selection of the question. They see my face. They see, they can feel a vulnerability from me coming through the relationship and that causes them to be vulnerable when I teach.

45:30 I'm very vulnerable when I teach because it communicates that being vulnerable for the participants of students is okay. And then they behave more vulnerably like that. So, you know, just thinking, about vulnerability. I don't know that I've ever had chat GPT or Claude tell me some vulnerable thing, you know, something they're worried about something there, you know,

45:55 that it's worried about or it's it's a mistake it made or you know, things like this. You see what I mean? And that's such a huge part of our human dimension is that none of us are perfect. And so so that is a I don't know. That's very much of a human thing in there is the friend.

The beauty in imperfection

46:14 I think the frailty. It's the it's the Japanese pottery, the Japanese ceremonial tea bowl that gets cracked and then they put it together with a goal with gold in there and then it becomes more. It becomes more precious than ever. The concepts wabi-sabi is the Japanese words. Is this it's the beauty in imperfection and and I think that the beauty in imperfection is part of what makes coaching between humans.

46:44 And conversations and relationships between humans so powerful. Yeah, and I think that's probably a really a really wonderful place to sort of land the conversation. This idea that because in reality as a coach and doesn't it coaching can often reveal the cracks in terms of you know, in in us and then that gives it that there's an opportunity for for healing in that process to figure out why did we behave a certain way? How do we do that? And so yeah, thank you. Keith.

47:14 That's just a really really insightful and I really I think a slightly different conversation than we've had before getting into the coaching, but I think it's helped us to really look into the more human aspects of well in general of our use of technology, particularly AI and actually how we interact with each other and what makes coaching such a powerful thing because of our humanness. I mean, that's what makes it makes it good. It's so good in terms of if people want to get in get in touch find out more about the,

47:44 the coaching. How do they do that? Yeah, then go to creative results management.com. And that is our training coaching training website. I also have a blog at Keith Webb.com and that's where I have leadership articles and articles on all kinds of things productivity leadership coaching things like that.

48:09 Amazing. Yeah, thank you thing. I guess thank you again, Keith and for those that are watching if you, if you liked what you see, not listen to them, please subscribe or follow which whatever channel that you are you're watching or listening to this on and if you want to know or hear about them with our topics different people you want to get on then just drop us a contact at better with humans.com. And we can get some other fantastic like Keith people like Keith on board. So yeah, thank you again, Keith. Great to have you. Well, Shaun, it's great to be on.

48:35 It's great to think about these. These are big challenges is how do we relate to machines that begin? Begin to sound more human even though they're not and how do we how do we do that? And we've been facing this challenge with social media for quite a while now for good 10 years. And so what does that look like? How do we relate?

49:00 And then how do we relate to each other? Yeah, that's it sounds like another great feature conversation around that. How yeah, what did lessons? What lessons have we not or not learned from social media? And how do we apply those two? So I but yeah, thank you again and catch you soon. Thank you.

Follow the Pod